Flying Saucer Working Party

Flying Saucer Working Party

From the UAP Encyclopedia, the open encyclopedia of UFO and UAP history · 🏢 Organization

Contents 7

Summary

The Flying Saucer Working Party was a secret committee established by the British Ministry of Defence in 1950 to conduct the government's first official study of UFO reports. Operating in Britain, the five-member committee examined reports for eight months and concluded in June 1951 that all sightings could be explained by natural phenomena, misidentifications, illusions, or hoaxes. The group strongly recommended that the government halt further investigations unless material evidence appeared.

Flying Saucer Working Party
Winston Churchill, who asked the Air Ministry in 1952 what the flying saucer reports amounted to
Winston Churchill, who asked the Air Ministry in 1952 what the flying saucer reports amounted to Photo: United Nations Information Office, New York · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons (resized copy)
TypeOrganization
Also known asFSWP

The Flying Saucer Working Party (FSWP) was a small secret committee set up by the British Ministry of Defence (MoD) in 1950 to study reports of flying saucers. It was the British government's first official study of UFOs.[1][2] Commissioned at the urging of the MoD's Chief Scientific Adviser, Sir Henry Tizard, it examined reports for eight months. In June 1951 it concluded that all of them could be explained, and it "very strongly" recommended no further investigation unless material evidence turned up.[1][2] The writer Nick Pope has called it "arguably the most marvellously-named committee in the history of the civil service".[1] Its report was thought lost until the researchers David Clarke and Andy Roberts found copies in 2001.[1][2]

Background

Flying saucer from the USA National Archives and Records Administration, cropped from the original here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Flying_Saucer_-_NARA_NAID_303938034.tif
Flying saucer from the USA National Archives and Records Administration, cropped from the original here: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Flying_Saucer_-_NARA_NAID_303938034.tif Photo: Unknown authorUnknown author · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons (resized copy)

By the summer of 1950, with war in Korea and the first Soviet atomic bomb raising tensions, flying saucer sightings were in the headlines on both sides of the Atlantic. The London Sunday Dispatch called the subject "bigger than the Atom Bomb Wars".[2] Clarke notes that air defence officers then had only seconds to decide whether an unidentified radar blip was a Soviet bomber, a missile or a phantom, so the saucers, real or not, could in principle trigger a war. Solving the problem became a priority for the CIA and its British counterpart, the MoD's Directorate of Scientific Intelligence (DSI). The DSI advised the Joint Intelligence Committee, which answered to the Prime Minister.[2]

Tizard, a scientific adviser trusted by Churchill and best known for his part in building Britain's pre-war radar defences, felt that saucer reports could not simply be dismissed as delusions and should have some proper scientific study.[1][2] According to Clarke, he was responding in part to a pro-saucer newspaper campaign backed by Lord Louis Mountbatten. Mountbatten and other senior figures, including Air Chief Marshal Hugh Dowding, the architect of the Battle of Britain, had privately concluded that saucers were advanced craft from outer space.[2]

Membership and work

Minutes of DSI and Joint Technical Intelligence Committee meetings found at The National Archives show that a team to study flying saucers was set up in August 1950, working closely with the CIA, which was running its own secret study.[2] The Wikipedia account dates the working party's creation to October 1950, the month of its first meeting.[1] It had five members from the technical intelligence branches of the Air Ministry, the Admiralty, the War Office and the Ministry of Defence. It first met in October 1950 in a room at the former Hotel Metropole on Northumberland Avenue, near Trafalgar Square.[2] RAF and Royal Navy personnel were asked to submit sighting reports.[2]

The three "reliable" cases

After eight months of sifting through hundreds of reports, from as far away as New Zealand, the working party judged that only three came from trustworthy sources and deserved further study:[2]

  • Tangmere, June 1950. A pilot from RAF Tangmere in Sussex saw a "bright circular metallic object" speed past his Meteor jet at 20,000 feet. At the same time, four RAF controllers at a radar station near Eastbourne tracked an "unusual response" that vanished at great speed.
  • Farnborough, August 1950. An experienced test pilot saw a flat, pearl-grey disc shaped like a shirt button make S-turns at up to 1,000 miles per hour over the Royal Aircraft Establishment at Farnborough.
  • Farnborough, two weeks later. The same pilot and five other senior RAF officers saw another disc perform high-speed manoeuvres and a "falling leaf" motion near Guildford and Farnham before diving towards the horizon. All six were questioned and told not to discuss it in public.

The working party concluded that the test pilot's first sighting was an optical illusion. It was "impossible to believe", it said, that an unconventional object could fly fast and low over a crowded area on a fine morning without anyone else reporting it. It judged that the other witnesses to the second sighting had been influenced by his first report, and that they had probably seen an ordinary aircraft "manoeuvring at extreme visual range".[2]

The report

Frederick Lindemann, Lord Cherwell, Churchill's scientific adviser, who endorsed the Air Ministry's reliance on the 1951 report
Frederick Lindemann, Lord Cherwell, Churchill's scientific adviser, who endorsed the Air Ministry's reliance on the 1951 report Photo: Unknown authorUnknown author or not provided · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons (resized copy)

The working party presented its six-page report, DSI/JTIC Report No. 7, "Unidentified Flying Objects", marked SECRET, to the Directorate of Scientific Intelligence in June 1951.[1][2] According to Clarke, the CIA's chief scientist, H. Marshall Chadwell, attended the meeting as a special guest.[2] See H. Marshall Chadwell.

  • Explanations. The report found that the reports could be explained by astronomical or meteorological phenomena; misidentified aircraft, balloons, birds and similar objects; optical illusions and psychological delusions; or deliberate hoaxes.[1][2]
  • Publicity. It shared the American view that peaks in sightings followed periods of media publicity, "indicating the extent to which sightings may be psychological in origin".[2]
  • Extraterrestrials. With only "a mass of purely subjective evidence", it said, it was impossible to prove scientifically whether the phenomena were or were not caused by something novel, such as craft of extraterrestrial origin.[2]
  • A crash story. The report recorded that a member of the US Air Force investigation team had told British intelligence that a sensational report of a crashed saucer full of "very small beings" had been admitted by its author to be a complete fabrication. Clarke argues that this shows Britain was given no hint of any recovered craft, such as at Roswell.[2]
  • Observation network. It said the only way to settle the question for good would be continuous observation of the skies by a coordinated network of observers with cameras, radar and sound locators. It judged that this would be an expensive and "singularly profitless enterprise".[2]
  • Recommendation. It ended: "We accordingly recommend very strongly that no further investigation of reported mysterious aerial phenomena be undertaken, unless and until some material evidence becomes available."[1]

Clarke argues that the report reflected American influence. The term "UFO" in its title had only recently been coined by the US Air Force, and its recommendations followed the American line of debunking sightings and keeping puzzling cases out of public view. He sees this as the birth of the belief that governments were hiding "the truth" about UFOs.[2]

Aftermath

HMS Vanguard during NATO Exercise Mainbrace in 1952, when saucers were reported by RAF and Royal Navy personnel
HMS Vanguard during NATO Exercise Mainbrace in 1952, when saucers were reported by RAF and Royal Navy personnel Photo: U.S. Naval Historical Center Photograph - Photo #: NH 103681 · Public domain · via Wikimedia Commons (resized copy)

A year later, in the summer of 1952, objects tracked on radar over Washington, D.C., revived concern in both countries. Prime Minister Winston Churchill wrote to his Secretary of State for Air, Lord De L'Isle and Dudley: "What does all this stuff about flying saucers amount to? What can it mean? What is the truth?"[2] The Air Ministry replied that a full intelligence study in 1951 had found that all the incidents could be explained by mistaken identity, delusions and hoaxes, and that the Americans agreed. Churchill's scientific adviser Lord Cherwell, a rival of Tizard, said he agreed entirely.[2]

Less than a month later, saucers were reported by RAF and Royal Navy personnel during the NATO exercise Mainbrace, prompting more headlines. Orders then went to all RAF stations invoking the Official Secrets Act to stop service personnel discussing sightings with the public or the press, on the grounds that the public gave RAF reports more credence than civilian ones. The classification was raised from restricted to confidential in 1956, and the secrecy lasted until the end of the Cold War.[2]

Rediscovery

The MoD long denied that it had ever carried out an official study of UFOs. When minutes of the committee came to light in 1999, the report itself could not be found, and staff at the Public Record Office said it had "not survived the passage of time".[2] In 2001, while researching their book Out of the Shadows, Clarke and Andy Roberts found copies in an MoD file labelled "Scientific intelligence". The MoD released it to them under the Code of Practice on Access to Government Information.[1][2] Clarke calls the report the "Holy Grail" for those who believed the MoD had covered up UFO evidence.[2]

References

Facts in this article are drawn in part from the Wikipedia article “Flying Saucer Working Party”, available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 licence.

This page was last edited on 31 October 2026. Articles are written in our own words from the sources listed under References; disputed claims are attributed to the people who made them.

Discuss the article: missing sources, mistakes, or what should be added.

No discussion yet.

GalleryBrowseFeedBoardsStatsFavoritesDownloads & postersSource Explorer Guides What’s that light?Starlink in the skyUAP explainedUFO newsUFO videos & documentariesArea 51Skinwalker RanchExplore by placeData reportsCollectionsWhat was that last night?UFO waves & burstsOfficial UFO files